Nissan Murano Forum banner

1 - 15 of 15 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I own a 2009 Murano SL, FWD. I bought it used with approximately 36000 miles. Around a year after I bought it, a problem arose, where only sometimes when starting from a stop, there is a noticeable clunk that you can hear and feel in the floor. The sound never happens when stopping suddenly or otherwise, or when reversing. The car now has around 70000 miles, and the sound is no worse, but I noticed this time while looking for a cause, there is a difference in the appearance of the rear sub-frame rear bracket bushings. Could this be a problem? I checked and the mounting bolt is not loose. Attached are pics of the left and right bushings.
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
523 Posts
Is that some type of fluid around the right rear one?

It may be a fluid filled bushing and may need to be replaced.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
407 Posts
I own a 2009 Murano SL, FWD. I bought it used with approximately 36000 miles. Around a year after I bought it, a problem arose, where only sometimes when starting from a stop, there is a noticeable clunk that you can hear and feel in the floor. The sound never happens when stopping suddenly or otherwise, or when reversing. The car now has around 70000 miles, and the sound is no worse, but I noticed this time while looking for a cause, there is a difference in the appearance of the rear sub-frame rear bracket bushings. Could this be a problem? I checked and the mounting bolt is not loose. Attached are pics of the left and right bushings.
Those pictures look like the rear bushings on the front subframe. The RH bushing (passenger side) looks like it's covered with fluid--probably water from the A/C drain. Bushings themselves look fine and given the condition of the subframe from what I can see and age of the car, you don't appear to live in the rust belt.

Clunk when accelerating from a stop--I'd suggest checking your motor mounts (esp. front). YouTube has lots of videos for testing motor mounts. Let us know what you find.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
All the motor mounts are ok, I have checked them every time (maybe 10 times now) I have attempted to track down the problem. Yes that is water running down the bushing, not oil or fluid. The bushing is rubber. My concern is the right bushing upper flange is dropped about 1/8" to 1/4" lower than the left. I guess it is hard to see in the picture. I had been driving in the rain before the pic was taken, so when it drys, I will try to get a better pic. If you look at the left pic, the surface of the flange of the bushing touching the sub-frame is what has dropped, but I can't figure out how.
And yes, the picture is of the front sub-frame rear corner brackets.
The help is appreciated.
Ken
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
407 Posts
All the motor mounts are ok, I have checked them every time (maybe 10 times now) I have attempted to track down the problem. Yes that is water running down the bushing, not oil or fluid. The bushing is rubber. My concern is the right bushing upper flange is dropped about 1/8" to 1/4" lower than the left. I guess it is hard to see in the picture. I had been driving in the rain before the pic was taken, so when it drys, I will try to get a better pic. If you look at the left pic, the surface of the flange of the bushing touching the sub-frame is what has dropped, but I can't figure out how.
And yes, the picture is of the front sub-frame rear corner brackets.
The help is appreciated.
Ken
Do you also hear the clunk when shifting from reverse into drive? How about if you torque brake to simulate a load on the engine?

I looked at the pictures again and I guess maybe there's a slight difference in space but not sure how meaningful that is. You can try prying on the subframe in that area with a big pry bar to see if it moves--it shouldn't.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
727 Posts
Do you also hear the clunk when shifting from reverse into drive? How about if you torque brake to simulate a load on the engine?
Not good advice considering how fragile the transfer case is on the Murano. These TC's are designed to be free wheeling 80% of the time, with rolling resistance while driving the rear wheels.

If you're in the habit of using the EB and repeatedly forgetting to disengage it before shifting into Drive/Reverse, you can expect to drastically decrease the life of your TC. Lockup stress can/will put cracks in the gears, like egg shells, in the TC. The several failed TC's I've seen had multiple cracks in the gears, usually with the main gear split in half. One smelled like it was burned, no oil.

Have a good day.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
407 Posts
Not good advice considering how fragile the transfer case is on the Murano. These TC's are designed to be free wheeling 80% of the time, with rolling resistance while driving the rear wheels.

If you're in the habit of using the EB and repeatedly forgetting to disengage it before shifting into Drive/Reverse, you can expect to drastically decrease the life of your TC. Lockup stress can/will put cracks in the gears, like egg shells, in the TC. The several failed TC's I've seen had multiple cracks in the gears, usually with the main gear split in half. One smelled like it was burned, no oil.

Have a good day.
I believe the OP has a front-wheel drive variant, but I agree that torque braking is stressful for the drivetrain. As such, it should only be done very briefly and purely for diagnostic purposes (...the Nissan service manual states, "Never hold down accelerator pedal for more than 5 seconds during this test.").
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
Have you also checked the exhaust clearance in relation to the underside of the car--yank it side to side and front to back?
Yes, exhaust is secure and all hangers are in great shape.

I have attempted to duplicate the sound/feel by hold brake and accelerating slightly forward and rearward, but only very briefly and only once. The only way I can get it to repeat, and then only "sometimes", is while driving forward and braking hard, then starting from a stop, accelerate hard, but normally when it happens is when accelerating normally.

I think someone referred to AWD, mine is FWD.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
I looked at the pictures again and I guess maybe there's a slight difference in space but not sure how meaningful that is. You can try prying on the subframe in that area with a big pry bar to see if it moves--it shouldn't.
[/QUOTE]

I missed your suggestion about prying on the sub-frame. Later this morning I am going to use my floor jack and see if this will move the bracket.
Thanks
Ken
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
407 Posts
I looked at the pictures again and I guess maybe there's a slight difference in space but not sure how meaningful that is. You can try prying on the subframe in that area with a big pry bar to see if it moves--it shouldn't.
I missed your suggestion about prying on the sub-frame. Later this morning I am going to use my floor jack and see if this will move the bracket.
Thanks
Ken
[/QUOTE]

The new information about hard braking and then hard acceleration with the noise might be helpful here. In that scenario, the front suspension is being loaded under the hard braking and then quickly unloaded with the hard acceleration.

Try putting the rear wheels of the car up on jack stands to simulate the front suspension being loaded under hard braking and then inspect all the front suspension components (including the subframe bushings) to see if anything stands out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
I have determined that the bushing is good. Looking closer with much better lighting and after the water evaporated, I can see that the top flange of the bushing is against the frame. I also attempted to move the bracket with a floor jack. It moves, but only slightly, like any rubber bushing.
Also, I did find the right engine mount is bad. I could not get the engine to move, but I realized the cover on top of the mount is removable. When I removed it, I could see the inside is collapsed. Pretty sure that this is the cause.

How can I check the front and rear mount? I can't get the engine to rock front to back, but I can't see the mounts very well either.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
407 Posts
I have determined that the bushing is good. Looking closer with much better lighting and after the water evaporated, I can see that the top flange of the bushing is against the frame. I also attempted to move the bracket with a floor jack. It moves, but only slightly, like any rubber bushing.
Also, I did find the right engine mount is bad. I could not get the engine to move, but I realized the cover on top of the mount is removable. When I removed it, I could see the inside is collapsed. Pretty sure that this is the cause.

How can I check the front and rear mount? I can't get the engine to rock front to back, but I can't see the mounts very well either.
The front and rear mounts themselves have a plastic cover so you can't actually see the condition of the rubber. You basically have to judge by engine movement. Shifting from D to R and back, there should be little movement (loading the engine via torque-braking helps--do it very briefly as discussed in previous posts). I think it's better to look right at the mounts when doing these tests. You can see the front mount from underneath just behind the radiator (...remove the undercover to get a better look at it).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter #15
The front and rear mounts themselves have a plastic cover so you can't actually see the condition of the rubber. You basically have to judge by engine movement. Shifting from D to R and back, there should be little movement (loading the engine via torque-braking helps--do it very briefly as discussed in previous posts). I think it's better to look right at the mounts when doing these tests. You can see the front mount from underneath just behind the radiator (...remove the undercover to get a better look at it).
Realized that after looking closer. My front and rear mounts have a rubber cover, which I can somewhat move up and out of the way, but it does not really help.
I will look at them again tomorrow and see if I can get any movement. I would like to find out now if the rear one is bad since I will have the axles out for a swap. The right outer CV joint boot is not clamped tight and it looks like it has been moving in and out a lot. I have 2 new axles, 2 new hubs (for a ticking on the left one, I have been listening to for almost a year that has started to get worse). So I would like to know since the axles will be out of the way to change it.
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top